Federal regulators have cleared AT&T to shut off traditional copper phone service for roughly 199,000 California homes and businesses starting in June, ending a three-decade guarantee that every resident in the state could reach a working landline.
The FCC voted along party lines on Friday to let AT&T retire copper lines at 360 wire centers across California, overriding the state's Carrier of Last Resort framework, a set of rules built 30 years ago to keep basic phone service available everywhere. The order finds that federal communications policy preempts the specific state requirements that had kept the copper network running. Chairman Brendan Carr dismisses the old framework as a relic of a bygone era, poorly suited to a market now crowded with fiber and wireless options.
AT&T spent years fighting California regulators over the issue, arguing that maintaining a network used by only about 3 percent of its California households costs roughly $1 billion a year, a figure pushed higher by a surge in copper theft. Freeing up that money, in the company's telling, allows it to extend fiber and wireless coverage to far more customers. Democratic Commissioner Anna Gomez dissented, warning that the commission moved to override state rules before California had finished writing its own transition plan.
Consumer advocates are vowing to keep fighting, arguing that residents will lose a legal right to phone service and, with it, dependable access to 911 during power outages, earthquakes and wildfires. AT&T counters that no customer will be left without voice or 911 access during the transition. A separate federal lawsuit the company filed against California's Public Utilities Commission and the state attorney general, which asks a court to declare that the state cannot block the shutdown, remains unresolved.