Kalshi says a New York attorney general order targeting its alleged illegal gambling operations could force the entire prediction-market exchange to shut down nationwide, wiping out trades customers have already placed across the country.
The warning came in a letter filed late Thursday, hours after a federal judge sent the legal battle back to Manhattan Supreme Court, where Attorney General Letitia James previously sought an emergency order barring contracts offered within or from New York. Kalshi, headquartered in the state, says that order would cripple an exchange handling $178 billion in annualized trading volume and carrying a $22 billion valuation, and an August Commodity Futures Trading Commission order warned a sudden shutdown could pose an existential threat.
James accuses Kalshi of running an unlicensed sports gambling business, letting customers as young as 18 bet despite the state minimum gambling age of 21, and offering wagers on New York college teams, which state law prohibits. Kalshi argues no urgency justifies an emergency injunction, noting it has operated since 2021 and offered sports contracts since January 2025, more than a year before the lawsuit. The company is urging Justice Melissa Crane to hold an immediate status conference and let it challenge any renewed temporary restraining order before one is issued.