Justice Department Sides With OpenAI in Landmark AI Copyright Battle

technology

The Justice Department has sided with OpenAI in a landmark legal battle over whether tech companies can train artificial intelligence on millions of newspaper articles without compensating the people who wrote them.

Several news organizations, including The New York Times, accuse OpenAI and Microsoft of infringing copyright protections by using their articles as AI training data. The tech firms argue the practice qualifies as fair use, the long-standing principle that allows limited use of copyrighted work without permission or payment.

A DOJ statement of interest backs OpenAI, contending that requiring licenses for training material would raise costs, disadvantage smaller competitors and threaten U.S. leadership and national security in artificial intelligence.

The stance breaks with a more balanced approach found elsewhere in the administration. The White House's AI framework weighs arguments on both sides, while the Carolina Principles, adopted by G20 ministers, emphasize the essential role of copyright in protecting creators.

Supporters of stronger protections warn that a broad fair-use exemption could erode the intellectual-property economy. Licensing creative work supports more than $1 trillion in U.S. economic activity, and weaker rights could mean fewer human-made books, films and songs, leaving AI systems with less high-quality material to learn from.

A bipartisan bill, the CLEAR Act, introduced in February by California Democrat Adam Schiff and Utah Republican John Curtis, would require AI developers to disclose the copyrighted works used to train each new generative model.