A Massachusetts boarding school ignored warnings about a beloved history teacher for more than twenty years while he allegedly groomed and raped students, and now the teacher and the school's former head both face criminal charges.
Matthew Rutledge taught at Miss Hall's for over three decades, chaired the history department, and collected faculty honors despite a paper trail of red flags, including a late-1990s incident in which a student who accused him of sex with another student was suspended, barred from graduation, and made to write him an apology letter. An outside investigation by Aleta Law, released in August 2025, substantiated grooming and abuse of at least five students and found leadership had been warned repeatedly while staff stayed quiet, some fearing retaliation and others assuming no one would listen. The same probe identified seven other employees who engaged in sexual misconduct with students dating to the 1940s.
Rutledge was indicted on three counts of rape in March and pleaded not guilty at his April arraignment, where survivors packed the courtroom wearing orange heart stickers. Former head of school Jeannie Norris has been indicted on a charge of reckless endangerment of a child and pleaded not guilty, as has a second former teacher facing charges including assault with intent to rape.
Two survivors turned their case into law, testifying at the State House until the Trusted Adults Act was signed in July, making it a felony for a teacher or coach to have sex with a student under eighteen. Massachusetts previously set the age of consent at sixteen, which had left prosecutors saying they could not charge him. One survivor's account reads simply: she spent twenty-two years believing she was the only one, until another alumna called.