The Best AI Tutors Can't Get Students to Show Up. A Human Can.

education

The finest AI learning tools can't make a student do the work, and only a person who is paying attention can.

Across 15 years running a tutoring marketplace in Israel, a team taught more than half a million lessons, then built a math app with over 10,000 exercises, full solutions in text and video, gamified rewards, and a free AI assistant that could walk a student through any step at any hour. By every product measure it was the best a student could get. Barely one in ten students used it, and most of those who started drifted away.

The same pattern showed up in a rigorous test of AI tutoring. A two-year randomized trial across 18 Tennessee middle schools, published this year, found that nearly every student tried Khan Academy's AI tutor Khanmigo, yet the typical student engaged on only a third of the days they practiced and in just 17% of the sessions where they got a problem wrong. The math gains matched plain practice with no AI at all, and only about 15% of students with access to it ever engage.

Then the equation flipped when the software stayed the same but the setup changed. Tutors began assigning each student's practice and following up at the next lesson, and completion climbed past 50%, up from roughly 10% on their own. Identical app, identical exercises. The only new ingredient was a human who knew the student and expected the work to get done.

The takeaway cuts against the AI-first classroom: content was never the bottleneck. Students already have more free, high-quality explanations than any generation in history. What they lack is someone who notices whether they showed up and cares how it went. AI can generate a perfect worksheet, but it can't make a 12-year-old feel that someone is counting on them.

The practical lesson for parents and school leaders is the same. Keep the AI, but keep a person in charge of it, someone who sets the goals and follows up. The future of learning isn't AI instead of teachers. It's a teacher in charge, with AI for everything in between.