A Los Angeles County medical examiner's report has rekindled a fierce debate over the death of 17-year-old Xavier Nungaray-Martinez by revealing he punched another male student and allegedly tried to forcibly kiss a female classmate in the moments before he went over a fourth-floor railing at Franklin High.
Xavier died September 30 at the school's Highland Park campus, and cellphone footage that spread widely online captured him being struck repeatedly in a classroom before he ran out and went over the railing as the other student closed in.
His family has said he was bullied, and the death pushed parents to demand stronger safety measures, including the return of school police to campuses.
The medical examiner's summary does not fully align with the video, which begins after Xavier's alleged provocations and shows him taking at least seven blows while down and not fighting back, with the other student later shouting a racial slur.
Attorney Michael Carrillo, who represents Xavier's father, dismissed the report as a rush to judgment and questioned whether the investigator had even watched the footage.
Attorneys for Xavier's parents have filed damage claims against the Los Angeles Unified School District, alleging it allowed dangerous conditions and failed to protect students, and noting he had been targeted and beaten during his sophomore year.
The examiner ruled the death a suicide from blunt head and torso injuries, a finding the family rejects, while toxicology showed Xavier was presumed positive for marijuana but detected no other substances and did not establish whether he was impaired at the time.