Johnny Depp Returns as Scrooge in a Comeback Disguised as Christmas Cheer

entertainment

Johnny Depp walks back onto American movie screens as Ebenezer Scrooge, and the role plays less like a career move than a public plea for forgiveness.

He stars in a new version of A Christmas Carol directed by horror filmmaker Ti West, a production that trades spectacle for thrift. Paramount paid Depp about 5 million dollars and spent roughly 38 million making the film, a cautious outlay for a star who once commanded 50 million per picture, though the studio has mounted a full marketing push.

The performance does the comeback no favors. Buried under gnarled prosthetics, Depp mugs his way through nearly two hours of cantankerous scowls and bug-eyed fright, veering into broad physical comedy that clashes with West's grim atmosphere. His Scrooge is less a miser than a hollow cartoon, closer to Oscar the Grouch than to Dickens.

By the time the ghosts arrive, the character is shrieking a message that sounds suspiciously personal. Grant me the grace to prove I am no longer the man I once was, he begs. Allow me my redemption, he insists, again and again.

The rehabilitation has been underway for years. Depp won a standing ovation at Cannes in 2023 for his turn as Louis XV in the French film Jeanne du Barry, directed Modigliani biopic Modi the following year, and in 2025 producer Jerry Bruckheimer confirmed talks about a sixth Pirates of the Caribbean film. He never lost his position as the face of Dior's Sauvage cologne either.

The damage he is trying to outrun stemmed from his divorce from Amber Heard, who alleged he was an abusive addict. Depp denied abusing her and sued, losing a case against a British tabloid that called him a wife-beater after a court found the description substantially true, while prevailing in a separate American defamation action over an op-ed in which Heard described herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse.

Both of his old studios moved on, paying out his full 16 million dollar exit from the Fantastic Beasts franchise while quietly shelving him. The Scrooge gamble asks audiences to see that as an injustice rather than a verdict.

Viewers can decide for themselves. As for this critic, the answer is bah, humbug.