Trump Order Could Turn Retired California Oil Rigs Into Permanent Seafloor Reefs

environment

A little-noticed directive inside a September executive order on recreational fishing is poised to leave aging oil platforms standing, or toppled, on the floor of the Pacific off California instead of hauling them to shore.

The order tasks the Interior Department's new Marine Minerals Administration with building a federal reef-in-place program, and a rulemaking set for 2027 would make toppling in place the default way to retire a platform, knocking the steel structure onto its side to rest on the seabed.

Twenty-three platforms operate in federal waters off the state, eight already in some stage of decommissioning, with four more in state waters. Federal estimates put full removal of the largest rigs above $200 million, and toppling has never been attempted in Pacific waters, where every retired platform to date has been fully removed.

Critics call the plan a giveaway that lets oil companies dodge hundreds of millions in costs, with coastal county groups labeling it ocean dumping and warning it also makes new remote drilling more attractive. Some scientists counter that the rigs host thriving rockfish, mussel and anemone communities, though Gulf of Mexico reefing data does not translate to California's depths and species.

A bipartisan bill, HR 5745, would ease conversion of rigs to reefs by shifting liability to states that accept them, while California's own 2010 program permits only partial removal, not toppling, and has never been used. Legal challenges are expected, complicated by the administration's effort to strip the state of its Coastal Zone Management Act authority over federal-water projects.